Dealers see Fiat profits — but when?
Don Lee thinks he can make money with Fiat and Alfa Romeo at a vacant showroom next to his dealership. The big question:
How long will it take?
“I think there’s a decent business case if you take the long view,” says Lee, president of Lee Dodge-Chrysler-Jeep in Westbrook, Maine.
Among the short-term concerns: Initially, Fiat will have just one model — the Fiat 500 minicar, scheduled to arrive late this year. Service revenue will be only a trickle at the beginning.
The Alfa Romeo brand will arrive in 2012, but it likely will be 2014 before the full Alfa lineup is in place.
And Chrysler Group gave no guarantees last week, at a meeting here with 400 prospective Fiat dealers, that those who sell Fiat also will get Alfa — although Chrysler CEO Sergio Marchionne has said they probably will.
On the plus side, Chrysler predicts healthy gross profits of up to $1,500 on each Fiat 500. Each dealership will get a large market area, and Fiat and Alfa should lure young customers to Chrysler Group dealerships.
So for dealers with capital and patience, the business case is attractive. At the beginning, though, it’s less so.
Go-slow strategy
Chrysler cleared one big hurdle with dealers last week by telling them they could start slowly and ramp up to a full dealership.
“To get there, some dealers are going to have to take it slower,” said Chrysler spokesman Ralph Kisiel. “They’ll have to offer a separate showroom but go beyond that as more product becomes available.”
The company did not issue specific requirements for showrooms and other items. Rather, Chrysler wants dealers to submit their best proposal for the Fiat franchise.
The go-slow approach surprised some dealers, who thought Chrysler was going to ask them to invest in a full, separate dealership right from the start.
Chrysler will choose 165 Fiat dealerships at first. Many will be in urban areas where the 500’s small size and miserly fuel economy will come in handy. The 500 is a retro-styled, two-door hatchback that is five inches shorter and about 300 pounds lighter than a Mini, a car often cited as a rival.
Chrysler has set Sept. 22 as the deadline for dealers to apply.
Got empty Saturn space?
Last week the company said a showroom of 2,500 to 3,000 square feet would be sufficient to start. Chrysler said dealerships with the Project Genesis Millennium design would work because that design has a separate used-car building where a Fiat showroom could be located. Dealerships that recently lost Saturn or Hummer franchises also would work.
Chrysler is asking for free-standing showrooms “of a reasonable size,” said Michael Maroone, COO of AutoNation Inc., the nation’s largest dealership group. “They’re not huge showrooms,” he said. “And I think over time there would be requirements to build a service facility, but not necessarily initially. I think you could do some commingling early, but ultimately I think it’s going to be different.”
So far, Maroone likes what he hears. “Based on the number of outlets, we think it’s a viable business,” he said. “The real key is the fact they’re only going to authorize 165 dealers initially. That allows people to both protect their margins and serve customers and be a little bit more aggressive.”
At the Detroit meeting, Chrysler talked about first-year Fiat 500 volumes of 50,000 cars, growing to 78,000 annually by 2013. That would mean sales would average 472 per dealership if the dealership count stays at 165.
But some dealers doubt Chrysler’s estimate on grosses of up to $1,500 per car. Lee says the number might be “a little optimistic.” But if Lee gets the franchise, he’ll be the only game in town in the Portland, Maine, area and won’t have to worry about competitors undercutting him on price.
Bill Golling, owner of Golling Chrysler-Dodge-Jeep in the Detroit suburb of Bloomfield Hills, Mich., says the arrival of a small car like the Fiat 500 will bring a new type of customer into Chrysler dealerships, which are used to selling minivans, Jeeps, pickups and large cars.
“If gas goes to $5 a gallon, it’s stand back, Irene,” says Golling, who says he probably will apply for a franchise.
Italian cachet
But the Fiat franchise is about more than selling a cute small car that sips gasoline. “There’s an understanding that there will be a re-entry of Italian cars in the United States,” says AutoNation’s Maroone. “They’re looking to create a separate culture in the stores and have a unique retail experience.”
Maroone says he went into the Aug. 30 presentation as a skeptic but emerged ready to apply for several franchises.
The chairman of another dealership group does not share Maroone’s optimism: “The Chrysler, Jeep and Dodge dealers are so weak, I don’t know how they can dilute it with all these extra brands and product. … If you look at small cars, even Minis are being discounted now.”
Lee, the Maine dealer, would like to know more about Chrysler’s own product plans because he doesn’t want products in his own showrooms competing with one another.
“I just hope they’re not going to make a mistake and start selling Fiats that have a Dodge or Chrysler badge on them,” he says.
The company has announced no plans to sell rebadged Fiat 500s, but it will sell Dodge- and Chrysler-badged compact cars based on Fiat platforms.
Lee hopes he will learn more when he goes to hear Marchionne address dealers Sept. 14 in Orlando and see Chrysler’s lineup.
Says Lee: “What I need to do is evaluate whether it’s worth investing in a Fiat franchise vs. acquiring a different franchise I would put in my facility.”
Source [AutomotiveNews]









